| R.B. Biggar | 1975-76 | Myrtle 337 |
| J.M. Plyley ∞ | 1978-79 | Dominion 615 |
| G.R. Sinnicks | 1983-84 | Centennial 679 |
| H.E. Mustard ∞ | 1984-85 | Merritt 168 |
| C.R.M. Stokes | 1986-87 | Adoniram 573 |
| K.G. Halbert | 1989-90 | Myrtle 337 |
| D.G. Martin | 1991-92 | King Edward VII 471 |
| H.J. Boutilier | 1992-93 | Clifton 254 |
| R.J. Muha | 1996-97 | Merritt 168 |
| N. McLean | 1998-99 | St. Mark's 105 |
| C.S. Gill | 2000-01 | Myrtle 337 |
| J. Fazekas | 2001-02 | Dominion 615 |
| J.E. Healey | 2002-03 | King Edward VII 471 |
| E.N. Garrow | 2003-04 | Clifton 254 |
| W. Adams | 2004-05 | Copestone 373 |
| D.R. Smith | 2005-06 | Phoenix 535 |
| R.W. Piper | 2006-07 | Merritt 168 |
| D.G.M. Lauder * | 2008-09 | Palmer 372 |
| S. Fuller | 2009-10 | Myrtle 337 |
| G. Hayward | 2010-11 | King Edward VII 471 |
| L. Williams | 2011-12 | Dominion 615 |
| T. McClellan * | 2012-13 | Clifton 254 |
| D. T. O'Neill ∞ | 2013-14 | Copestone 373 |
| T. Beattie | 2014-15 | Phoenix 535 |
| G.A. Faraday | 2015-16 | Merritt 168 |
| N.I. Andras | 2016-17 | Adoniram 573 |
| R. G. Jordan | 2017-18 | Macnab 169 |
| M. J. Ferguson | 2018-19 | St. Marks 105 |
| J.F.C. Newton | 2019-21 | Palmer 372 |
| D. J. Plyley | 2021-23 | Dominion 615 |
| * Demitted | ∞ Deceased |
| J.T. Hesketh | 1987 | Centennial 679 |
| T. McKay | 1988 | St Mark’s 105 |
| L.W. Nigh | 1989 | Palmer 372 |
| E.F. Goodyear | 1990 | Centennial 679 |
| J.A. Whitwell | 1990 | Myrtle 337 |
| W.J. Boutilier | 1993 | Clifton 254 |
| R. Judge | 1994 | Stamford 626 |
| W.D.J. Weir ∞ | 1995 | Copestone 373 |
| V.F. Wilson | 1995 | Fort Erie 613 |
| G. Cook | 1996 | Phoenix 535 |
| K. Eller ∞ | 1998 | Phoenix 535 |
| E. Jones | 1998 | Adoniram 573 |
| K. Green ∞ | 1999 | St. Mark’s 105 |
| T. Bedell | 2000 | Palmer 372 |
| G.R. Cook | 2000 | Clifton 254 |
| J. Chapman ∞ | 2002 | Dominion 615 |
| L. Stewart | 2003 | King Edward VII 471 |
| E.R. Auger | 2004 | King Edward VII 471 |
| R. Simpson ∞ | 2004 | Palmer 372 |
| G. White | 2004 | Clifton 254 |
| W. Burnett | 2005 | Copestone 373 |
| L.J. Peyton | 2006 | Macnab 169 |
| R.C. Watson | 2006 | Phoenix 535 |
| R.T. Shave | 2007 | Merritt 168 |
| M. Morgan ∞ | 2008 | St. Mark’s 105 |
| T.F. Tkach | 2008 | Adoniram 573 |
| R.L Cudney Sr. ∞ | 2009 | Palmer 372 |
| W. Dzierba | 2009 | Copestone 373 |
| G. Schmidt | 2009 | Merritt 168 |
| R.M. Chalmers | 2010 | Clifton 254 |
| J.H. Perham | 2010 | Palmer 372 |
| B. Wallace ∞ | 2010 | Myrtle 337 |
| R.B.S. Ennest | 2011 | King Edward VII 471 |
| J. Nigh | 2012 | Dominion 615 |
| B. Radford | 2013 | Clifton 254 |
| M. Davenport | 2013 | Palmer 372 |
| J. Harkness | 2013 | Adoniram 573 |
| B. Bitner | 2014 | Macnab 169 |
| A. Gill ∞ | 2014 | Myrtle 337 |
| R.A.R. Ennest ∞ | 2014 | King Edward VII 471 |
| K. McClatchie | 2015 | Phoenix 535 |
| A.D. McCorquodale ∞ | 2016 | Merritt 168 |
| C.A. Wright | 2017 | Adoniram 573 |
| K.J. Hooper | 2017 | Palmer 372 |
| S. Penwarden | 2017 | Merritt 168 |
| K. Burke | 2018 | Macnab 169 |
| S. R. Ferguson | 2019 | St. Marks 105 |
| T. A. Whitfield | 2021 | Palmer 372 |
| P. Kingston | 2023 | Merritt 168 |